Scale of violent assaults remains high
The Council of Europe area has suffered a "marked setback" in the overall level of media freedom in the past three years, according to a background report by an independent expert presented today to PACE's Sub-committee on the Media.
The country-by-country report, by the academic and former BBC senior correspondent William Horsley, was commissioned as a contribution to a PACE report on media freedom being prepared by the sub-committee's Chair Andrew McIntosh (United Kingdom, SOC), and presented at a PACE hearing today in Luxembourg. It gathers data from several NGOs monitoring journalists' freedom, who also contributed to the hearing.
"It is apparent from this survey of the last three years that the violations and abuses are more acute and pervasive than has been widely understood," according to the report.
At least 20 journalists have been killed on duty apparently because of their work since the start of 2007, the report points out - compared with 13 deaths in the preceding three years - while the scale of violent assaults remains unacceptably high. The great majority of targeted killings or serious assaults took place in Russia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Moldova and Belarus, but cases were also recorded in Turkey, Croatia, Serbia, Greece and Spain.
The spread of freedom of information laws, as well as the decriminalisation of libel and abolition of blasphemy in some states, are positive developments, but "often the effect has been blunted by contrary trends towards more controls and interference in media independence", the report concludes.
Below is an extract about Armenia:
Armenia
52. Harassment of journalists and direct controls on the media intensified around the time of the February 2009 presidential election. Several journalists including photographer Gagik Shamshyan were injured in assaults by police during protests after the election. CPJ reported that a reporter, Lusine Barseghyan, was assaulted while attempting to document abuses at a Yerevan polling station. During a three-week long State of Emergency all independent reporting was banned. In March 2007 similar government controls on the media were imposed during a temporary State of Emergency under the previous administration.
53. Several other journalists suffered assaults in 2008, including Hrach Melkumyan, Yerevan bureau chief of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and Edik Baghdasaryan, editor of the online news magazine Hetq and chair of Armenian Association of Investigative Journalists.
54. On 30 April 2009 Argishti Kivirian, editor of the online news website Armenia Today, was attacked by three unknown assailants outside his home in Yerevan, leaving him with severe injuries. He was reportedly beaten on his head and body with clubs or wooden poles and one of the attackers also fired gunshots which caused no injuries. Colleagues said they believed the attack was related to his work.