Open news feed Close news feed
A A

''A1+'' contests don't count?

Social

"One hand washes another," this was how president of the "A1+" TV/"Meltex" LTD Mesrop Movsesyan weighed up the verdict reached by the Cassation Court.

The Cassation Court denied today the two lawsuits filed against the court to reverse the verdicts reached by the Cassation Court on 2004 February 27 and 2004 April 23. "Meltex" LTD had appealed to the Cassation Court on the grounds of revelation of new reasons and the new reason was the verdict of the European Court against the RA. During the previous trial Judge of the Cassation Court Arman Mkrtumyan had noted that even the European Court had recorded that the Cassation Court had functioned within the framework of the law in 2003 and 2004.

What remained unclear was why the Cassation Court denied the two lawsuits filed by "A1+". Arman Mkrtumyan told "A1+" correspondents that they could find the reasons for denial in the justification section of the verdict of the Cassation Court, which was not released today.

"The judge only released the concluding section of the verdict and reminded that the Ministerial Committee of the Council of Europe has assigned the RA to change the law on "Television and Radio" so that the resolutions of the National Commission on Television and Radio" will be clarified," said "A1+"'s representative in court Artak Zeynalyan.

The fact of the matter is that the European Court and the Cassation Court believe that the National Commission on Television and Radio violated the rights of "A1+". During the previous session judge of the Cassation Court told "A1+" representatives that they had sent the appeal to a "wrong" address.

"If the Cassation Court has instigated a revision case, which means that we have addressed the right person. Yes, "A1+"'s rights were violated by the National Commission on Television and Radio and the only place to restore those rights is the court," said Artak Zeynalyan.

Accepting today's denials of the Cassation Court as a basis, Zeynalyan said:

"The fight of the authorities against "A1+" continues."

President of "A1+" added:

"The authorities continue to work as a team to defend themselves from "A1+". That is the strategy of a culprit."

"A1+" will continue to restore its violated rights in the legal field, but Mesrop Movsesyan says that it is too early to talk about further steps as long as the substantiations of the verdicts of the Cassation Court are not in his hands. According to Mesrop Movsesyan, there is only one explanation for the verdict of the Cassation Court.

"This means that everybody accepts the fact that the National Commission on Television and Radio has violated the rights of "A1+" several times and the courts have not put an end to that when it was the time to do that; otherwise, the case would not end up in the European Court. The courts are now disregarding the verdicts, the Commission and are turning the law into a scapegoat. In other words, the courts say that they will change the law and there will not be any more violations of rights of people taking part in the contest," added Mr. Movsesyan.

"Does this mean that what happened to "A1+" doesn't count and that we are playing with new rules of the game, "Uncle Europe"? That is not how you build a country. This is a short-sighted mentality with which the authorities continue to throw down the reputation of the country. "A1+" will sooner or later restore its violated rights, but it will be very difficult to raise the reputation of the country. What's bad for the authorities is that they solve everything through childish actions, but manly behavior means living by the laws-something which is very difficult to do in Armenia."